Rent vs Buy Calculator

Compare buying a home with renting and investing the difference: your wealth each year, and the year buying starts to pay off.

Advertisement
In short

Buying a 500,000 home with 20% down at 6.5% against renting at 2,200 a month (both growing 3% a year, savings earning 6%): after 10 years the buyer is worth about 292,536 and the renter 367,825; renting stays ahead for the whole 10 years.

Rent vs buy calculator
any currency · runs in your browser
Net worth year by year
YearBuyRentAhead

The words on this page, explained simply

New to this? Here is what each term means, in plain English.

Price-to-rent ratio
A home's price divided by a year's rent; the higher it is, the more renting tends to pay.
Buying and selling costs
Transfer or stamp duty, legal and agent fees paid when a home is bought or sold.
Home equity
What the home would sell for, less selling costs and the mortgage still owed.
Compound interest
Interest earned on earlier interest as well as on the original amount, so growth snowballs over time.

Comparing rent with a mortgage payment misses most of the money. A buyer also pays upfront costs, upkeep and selling costs, and builds equity; a renter keeps the down payment invested. This calculator follows both month by month and compares what each owns at the end, so the answer depends on your own prices, rates and how long you stay.

How the comparison works

The buyer pays the down payment and buying costs (transfer or stamp duty, legal fees), then the mortgage payment and ownership costs each month: maintenance, property tax and insurance, entered as a percentage of the home's value. At the end the home is sold, less selling costs, and the remaining loan is repaid.

The renter invests the same upfront cash at the investment return. Each month, whichever of the two spends less invests the difference, so both have spent the same money. Rent rises once a year; the home's value grows monthly.

Taxes are left out: mortgage interest relief, tax on investment gains and on a home sale differ by country.

What decides the answer

How long you stay matters most: buying and selling costs need years of price growth and repayment to recover. After that, the gap between home price growth and the investment return, the mortgage rate, and the rent compared with the price (the price-to-rent ratio) decide the winner.

StayBuyer's net worthRenter's net worth
1 years88,571136,358
3 years127,913181,445
5 years170,415229,915
7 years216,376282,053
10 years292,536367,825

For the example above.

Key takeaways

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to rent or buy a house?

It depends on how long you stay, the price compared with the rent, the mortgage rate, how fast prices and rents grow, and what you would earn investing the down payment. Over a few years renting usually wins because of buying and selling costs; over long stays buying often does.

What is the price-to-rent ratio?

The home price divided by a year's rent. The higher it is, the more renting tends to win; a 500,000 home renting at 2,200 a month has a ratio of about 19.

Does the calculator include taxes?

No. Mortgage interest relief, capital gains rules on a home and on investments, and property taxes beyond the upkeep percentage differ by country, so they are left out.

Why does the renter invest the difference?

So the two choices spend the same money each month. A renter who spends the savings instead would end up worse off than this shows.

Related tools and pages