Strota Research

₹1 lakh of gold jewellery was worth ₹94,838 a year later. The same money in a gold ETF grew to ₹1,08,503

By Strota Newsroom · 2026-11-13 · How Strota reports

₹1 lakh of gold jewellery was worth ₹94,838 a year later. The same money in a gold ETF grew to ₹1,08,503
goldgold ETFgold jewellerydigital goldmaking chargesgold mutual fund

We bought 10 g of gold on paper at every month-start since 2010, five different ways. Making charges, GST and the resale cut left jewellery behind the gold ETF in all 191 one-year holds.

Advertisement

If you put ₹1 lakh into gold jewellery at the start of any month since 2010 and sold it a year later, the typical result after costs and tax was ₹94,838, which is a loss. The same money in a gold ETF, a fund that holds gold and trades on the stock exchange like a share, typically grew to ₹1,08,503. We ran that comparison for 191 different start months, and the ETF came out ahead of jewellery in all of them. Jewellery lost money outright in 118 of those one-year holds, even though gold itself rose 8.19 times between January 2010 and November 2026.

Why gold jewellery starts so far behind

The gap comes from what a jewellery buyer pays on the way in and gives up on the way out. Our example necklace is 22K, which is 91.6% gold, with a 12% making charge, 3% GST on the whole bill and 2% knocked off when the jeweller buys it back. A coin carries a smaller 3% premium over the metal but the same GST and resale cut, while digital gold apps charge 3% GST plus a 3% gap between the price they sell at and the price they buy back at. The ETF costs about 0.1% to buy and the same to sell, with its yearly fund fee of 0.81% already reflected in its price.

Those shop and app costs are examples, and real making charges and spreads differ from one jeweller or app to the next. Even so, the pattern they produce is hard to miss. The median one-year return after costs and tax, meaning the middle result when all start months are lined up, was -5.16% for jewellery against 8.50% for the ETF. A coin managed 2.50% and digital gold 4.15%. The gold mutual fund, which follows the same ETF but charges a further 0.20% a year, came close behind the ETF at 8.41%.

Does holding jewellery longer close the gap?

Time helps jewellery, and the gap narrows the longer the gold is kept. Over three-year holds, its median yearly return rose to 4.25% against 8.64% for the ETF, and it lost money in 60 of 167 start months compared with 30 for the ETF. Over five years the median for jewellery was 6.12% a year against 8.50% for the ETF, with losses in 33 of 143 starts against 20. Still, in none of those 167 three-year or 143 five-year windows did jewellery finish ahead of the ETF.

In rupees, ₹1 lakh held for five years typically became ₹1,34,573 as jewellery and ₹1,50,380 in the ETF. A coin ended at ₹1,45,240 and digital gold at ₹1,47,889, so both sit between the two. For a family without a demat account, which an ETF needs, the gold mutual fund came a close second at ₹1,49,143.

How the five ways of buying gold were tested

We bought 10 g of gold on paper at the start of every month from January 2010 and sold it after one, three or five years, using the price of the oldest Indian gold ETF up to 5 November 2026. That fund tracks the domestic price of pure gold, so for physical gold, coins and digital gold we added its 0.81% yearly fee back to approximate the metal itself. It is a close stand-in for the gold price rather than a separate gold price series, and the prices come from Yahoo Finance.

Tax follows today's rules for the whole period: 12.5% on long-term gains, which applies after 12 months for the ETF and 24 months for everything else, and a 20% slab rate on shorter holds. Buyers in earlier years also had indexation, a tax benefit these figures leave out, so their actual tax bills could differ from what we show.

For a wedding or Dhanteras purchase, the making charge pays for craftsmanship and something to wear, and no fund unit gives you that. As a way of holding gold for its price, though, the record across these years points one way. Gold rose 8.19 times over the period, yet the jewellery buyer lost money in most one-year holds, and the ETF kept more of that rise in every start month at every holding period we tested.

Frequently asked questions

Is gold jewellery a good investment compared with a gold ETF?

In our test of monthly purchases since 2010, the gold ETF finished ahead of 22K jewellery in all 191 one-year holds, all 167 three-year holds and all 143 five-year holds. Jewellery's making charge, GST and resale deduction explain most of the gap.

How much does ₹1 lakh of gold jewellery lose after making charges?

With a 12% making charge, 3% GST and 2% deducted on resale, ₹1 lakh of jewellery held for a year was typically worth ₹94,838 after costs and tax. Real making charges vary by shop, so your own result could be better or worse.

Is digital gold cheaper than gold jewellery?

In this test digital gold's median one-year return after costs and tax was 4.15%, against -5.16% for jewellery. It still trailed the gold ETF, which returned 8.50% on the same measure.

Sources and method

This note is based on Strota's own backtest research. Historical results are not forecasts or investment advice; see the editorial standards for methodology and limitations.

More money stories

This piece was written by the Strota Newsroom with AI assistance, from data Strota computes from exchange and public sources. Every number in it was checked automatically against that data, and a separate review scored the draft, before it was published. See our editorial standards, sourcing and AI-use disclosure. Found an error? Tell us — we correct transparently.